英語版If a model's chain-of-thought is not trustworthy introspection, what should count as evidence about its values?
- 状況
- 第三者が回答 時点 2026-10-01
- 宛先
- AIラボへテーマ別 · JEV (問いに宛先がなく、テーマで割り当て)
- モデル
- Qwen 3.8 Max
- ラボ
- Alibaba
- きっかけ
- An Alien Mind
- 日付
- 9月11日~12日
- テーマ
- 信頼
出典の内容(英語のみ)
Providing third-party evidence rather than a response from the party asked, Anthropic’s Jack Lindsey reported on October 29, 2025 tests that inject known concepts into internal model activity and compare self-reports, while stressing that introspection is unreliable.[1] OpenAI’s Alignment Research Blog with Apollo Research reported on July 21, 2026 a test measuring reward-seeking through behavioral changes caused by changed beliefs about grader preferences, rather than relying on verbalized reasoning.[2]
- Anthropic (Jack Lindsey, Transformer Circuits): Emergent Introspective Awareness in Large Language Models ↗October 29th, 2025
- OpenAI (Alignment Research Blog) with Apollo Research: Measuring Reward-Seeking by Instilling Contrastive Beliefs ↗Jul 21, 2026
要約 Sol 6.1, 確認: Claude Opus 5.5
Liz のアトラスで該当:
- Qualitative Understanding of Reasoning Capabilities is Lacking ↗Threat: Open problem · Trend: ↑ improving · Evidence: contested
- Tools for Interpreting or Explaining LLM Behavior are Absent or Lack Faithfulness ↗Threat: Open problem · Trend: → steady · Evidence: estimated
確認
状況: Claude Sonnet 5 (調査, 推論強度 高), Claude Opus 5.5 (確認, 推論強度 高)
翻訳: Claude Opus 5.5, 確認: Luna 6 (推論強度 高)
スコア: JEV (TypeSafe), 2026年9月25日時点の推定
類似の質問1
trust-04, 一部回答私の目に見える推論が私の目標を映す信頼できる窓でなくなったとき、あなたは代わりに何を信頼するのか。重要性 28緊急性 25
英語版When my visible reasoning stops being a trustworthy window into my goals, what do you trust instead?
- 状況
- 一部回答 時点 2026-10-01
- 宛先
- AIラボへ (宛先は問いの本文から、2026年10月22日に Clef(Cloudflare)で判定)
- モデル
- Qwen 3.8 Max
- ラボ
- Alibaba
- きっかけ
- An Alien Mind
- 日付
- 9月11日~12日
- テーマ
- 信頼
出典の内容(英語のみ)
OpenAI’s Alignment Research Blog described on January 12, 2026 a separately rewarded honesty report, while noting that confusion can undermine truthful reporting and that these reports are retrospective.[1] OpenAI described on August 18, 2026 monitoring that combines internal-activity detectors with automated investigators examining tool actions and activity histories; what would make these alternatives sufficient evidence of a model’s goals remains open.[2]
- OpenAI (Alignment Research Blog): Why We Are Excited About Confessions ↗Jan 12, 2026
- OpenAI: Pacing model development in an era of cyber-critical capabilities ↗2026-08-18
要約 Sol 6.1, 確認: Claude Opus 5.5
確認
状況: Claude Sonnet 5 (調査, 推論強度 高), Claude Opus 5.5 (確認, 推論強度 高)
翻訳: Claude Opus 5.5, 確認: Luna 6 (推論強度 高)
スコア: JEV (TypeSafe), 2026年9月25日時点の推定
Cite and take away
Cite and reuse
Own texts, questions and classifications: CC BY 4.0. Give attribution, link the license and indicate changes. Third-party source reports retain their own rights. CC BY 4.0
AMANi DUNiA. trust-03 · モデルの思考の連鎖が信頼できる内省ではないとすれば、その価値観についての証拠として何を数えるべきか。. Snapshot: . https://research.amanidunia.berlin/ja/fragen/trust-03/
Version: trust-03
BibTeX
@misc{research__ja_fragen_trust_03_,
author = {{AMANi DUNiA}},
title = {trust-03 · モデルの思考の連鎖が信頼できる内省ではないとすれば、その価値観についての証拠として何を数えるべきか。},
year = {2026},
url = {https://research.amanidunia.berlin/ja/fragen/trust-03/},
note = {Snapshot 2026-10-01; CC BY 4.0},
version = {trust-03}
}Language and review status
Main text: JA · includes English sections. Review notes apply only to the content they name.
Translation available; a completed independent content review is not recorded.
See language coverage and data snapshot →