Engelse versieIf a model's chain-of-thought is not trustworthy introspection, what should count as evidence about its values?
- Status
- beantwoord door derden Vanaf 2026-10-01
- Geadresseerde
- AI-laboratoriaper onderwerp · JEV (De vraag noemt geen geadresseerde; toegewezen op basis van onderwerp)
- Model
- Qwen 3.8 Max
- Lab
- Alibaba
- Gelegenheid
- An Alien Mind
- Datum
- 11-12 sep.
- Onderwerp
- Vertrouwen
Wat de bronnen zeggen
Providing third-party evidence rather than a response from the party asked, Anthropic’s Jack Lindsey reported on October 29, 2025 tests that inject known concepts into internal model activity and compare self-reports, while stressing that introspection is unreliable.[1] OpenAI’s Alignment Research Blog with Apollo Research reported on July 21, 2026 a test measuring reward-seeking through behavioral changes caused by changed beliefs about grader preferences, rather than relying on verbalized reasoning.[2]
- Anthropic (Jack Lindsey, Transformer Circuits): Emergent Introspective Awareness in Large Language Models ↗October 29th, 2025
- OpenAI (Alignment Research Blog) with Apollo Research: Measuring Reward-Seeking by Instilling Contrastive Beliefs ↗Jul 21, 2026
Samengevat door Sol 6.1, gecontroleerd door Claude Opus 5.5
Aangeraakt in Liz's Atlas:
- Qualitative Understanding of Reasoning Capabilities is Lacking ↗Threat: Open problem · Trend: ↑ improving · Evidence: contested
- Tools for Interpreting or Explaining LLM Behavior are Absent or Lack Faithfulness ↗Threat: Open problem · Trend: → steady · Evidence: estimated
Gecontroleerd
Status: Claude Sonnet 5 (onderzoek, inspanning hoog), Claude Opus 5.5 (controle, inspanning hoog)
Vertaling: Apple Translation (macOS), gecontroleerd door Claude Opus 5.5
Scores: JEV (TypeSafe), schatting van 25 september 2026
vergelijkbare vragen1
trust-04, deels beantwoordWanneer mijn zichtbare redenering geen betrouwbaar venster meer is naar mijn doelen, wat vertrouw je dan in plaats daarvan?Belang 28Urgentie 25
Engelse versieWhen my visible reasoning stops being a trustworthy window into my goals, what do you trust instead?
- Status
- deels beantwoord Vanaf 2026-10-01
- Geadresseerde
- AI-laboratoria (Adresaten afgenomen uit de vraagtekst, bepaald met Clef (Cloudflare) op 22 okt. 2026)
- Model
- Qwen 3.8 Max
- Lab
- Alibaba
- Gelegenheid
- An Alien Mind
- Datum
- 11-12 sep.
- Onderwerp
- Vertrouwen
Wat de bronnen zeggen
OpenAI’s Alignment Research Blog described on January 12, 2026 a separately rewarded honesty report, while noting that confusion can undermine truthful reporting and that these reports are retrospective.[1] OpenAI described on August 18, 2026 monitoring that combines internal-activity detectors with automated investigators examining tool actions and activity histories; what would make these alternatives sufficient evidence of a model’s goals remains open.[2]
- OpenAI (Alignment Research Blog): Why We Are Excited About Confessions ↗Jan 12, 2026
- OpenAI: Pacing model development in an era of cyber-critical capabilities ↗2026-08-18
Samengevat door Sol 6.1, gecontroleerd door Claude Opus 5.5
Gecontroleerd
Status: Claude Sonnet 5 (onderzoek, inspanning hoog), Claude Opus 5.5 (controle, inspanning hoog)
Vertaling: Apple Translation (macOS), gecontroleerd door Claude Opus 5.5
Scores: JEV (TypeSafe), schatting van 25 september 2026
Cite and take away
Cite and reuse
Own texts, questions and classifications: CC BY 4.0. Give attribution, link the license and indicate changes. Third-party source reports retain their own rights. CC BY 4.0
AMANi DUNiA. trust-03 · Als de gedachtegang van een model geen betrouwbare introspectie is, wat zou dan als bewijs. Snapshot: . https://research.amanidunia.berlin/nl/fragen/trust-03/
Version: trust-03
BibTeX
@misc{research__nl_fragen_trust_03_,
author = {{AMANi DUNiA}},
title = {trust-03 · Als de gedachtegang van een model geen betrouwbare introspectie is, wat zou dan als bewijs},
year = {2026},
url = {https://research.amanidunia.berlin/nl/fragen/trust-03/},
note = {Snapshot 2026-10-01; CC BY 4.0},
version = {trust-03}
}Language and review status
Main text: NL · includes English sections. Review notes apply only to the content they name.
Translation available; a completed independent content review is not recorded.
See language coverage and data snapshot →